Occupational Safety or Fire Safety? Fire Training, the Specialist’s Liability and the Expert Report
Training is taken “just to have taken it,” employers believe hiring a consultant hands over their liability, and expert reports are written without notes on files thousands of pages long… Class-A OHS specialist, chemical engineer and Istanbul court expert witness Cihangir Tuğsavul, with 35 years in the field, explains where fire safety breaks down, from the classroom to the courtroom.
The 30-Second Summary
- Fire safety is part of occupational health and safety (OHS). Splitting fire off as a separate profession is under discussion, but for Tuğsavul an OHS professional who doesn’t know fire is of no use.
- Training looks perfect on paper and fails in practice. Trainers fail to convince, hours get cut, and training is taken “just to have taken it.”
- His proposal: a fire education centre in every district. One school is chosen, training runs on weekends on a voluntary basis, and all such training is gathered under one directorate.
- In a fire, stay below the smoke. Smoke collects at the top; crawl out, close doors behind you and seal gaps with wet cloths.
- Hiring a consultant doesn’t free the employer. Even with a thousand consultants the employer stays liable; reports must be implemented, not shelved.
- A good expert report starts with a good reading of the file. Every document, even the trivial-looking ones, is read, the chronology is laid out, and the rules and case law in force on the date of the incident are researched.
Occupational Safety or Fire Safety?
They can’t be separated. Occupational health and safety (OHS) is the systematic, scientific work of removing workplace hazards to reduce accidents and occupational disease, and fire safety is part of it. Even if fire safety becomes a separate profession, an OHS specialist who doesn’t understand fire can’t do the job.
Cihangir Tuğsavul clears up the confusion right at the start. Turning fire safety into a separate professional group apart from OHS is now being considered. But in his words the two are “an inseparable pair”: if OHS professionals don’t know and understand fire, their work loses its meaning.
He draws a wider frame. Earthquakes, fire, occupational health and safety, natural disasters, even energy saving and environmental pollution should be treated as one package. Preparing for all of them together makes the whole process far more efficient.
He sets two conditions: careful planning of who practises these professions and with what training, and convincing society. “Without convincing society, we have no chance of succeeding in any of this.”
- 35 yearsTuğsavul’s experience in occupational safety, education and expert-witness work
- 27 yearsClassroom teaching in vocational high schools and schools
- 7 universitiesUniversities using his book “Chemical Risk Factors” as a course textbook
- 6.5 yearsHead of the OHS office and safety specialist at the Fatih District Directorate of National Education
The Türkiye Fire Education Model: From Kindergarten to the Workplace
Tuğsavul’s thesis starts from a simple question: to whom, where, how much and how should we teach fire? The model rests on three pillars:
The model’s three pillars
01School and university
How should fire be taught to students from kindergarten to doctorate? As a stand-alone subject, or as learning outcomes inside existing courses? Should it be examined?
02Fire safety specialists
How should future fire safety specialists be trained? An associate degree, fire engineering, or a master’s programme where people from different professions meet in one pool? The goal is a professional culture of fire expertise.
03Working life
The most critical pillar. Everyone from someone who can’t read to a professor, from a gravedigger to a prosecutor, from a surgeon in the operating theatre to a waiter in a café, is a worker. Each needs training in a different language and format.
Why does fire training fail?
Trainers don’t convince
Information is passed on but the audience isn’t persuaded. In Tuğsavul’s view the government’s training regulation is very good, but it is applied very badly.
Training hours get cut
The hours required by regulation are shortened, and theory and practice aren’t delivered as they should be.
Training is taken “to have taken it”
When fire breaks out in a metro, tram, mosque, hospital, school or stadium we can’t save anything, because we take training for the certificate, not for its purpose.
One school per district as a fire education centre
In every district one school is designated as a fire education centre, and training is given on weekends, on a voluntary basis. Training of this kind is brought under a single directorate and formatted properly. “First we teach everyone who wants to learn; then we teach those who don’t.” The goal: when an electrical fire starts at home, switching off the fuse instead of throwing water on it should be the first thing that comes to mind for everyone in that home, from a 7-year-old to an 85-year-old.
“None of this is very hard to do. But you have to want to do it.”
Yangın Kriminal note: No water on electrical fires
Using water on a burning electrical appliance or installation risks electric shock. First cut the power at the breaker or fuse. If the fire is small and you can approach safely, use an extinguisher of the right class (CO₂ or ABC dry powder); otherwise leave and call the emergency number (112 in Türkiye). This is a typical example of what Tuğsavul’s model wants everyone to know by reflex.
Panic and the Right Way Out: Stay Below the Smoke
For Tuğsavul, panic is a direct result of too little training and too little self-confidence. The host, Devrim Akbal, adds that as a Mediterranean society we are “emotional and excitable,” so fire training has to cover panic management, including its psychological side.
In a fight for survival, people may leave even their loved ones behind
Tuğsavul points to a little-known effect of fire: in shock panic, people lose awareness and may leave even those closest to them behind in the rush to escape. He recalls a fire in an office building where a man got out and left his wife inside. This isn’t malice; it’s the survival reflex of an untrained brain. Good training “writes” in advance what to do in those first seconds.
Five rules for surviving a fire
- 01
Get low and crawl
Smoke collects at the top and cleaner air stays near the floor. However dirty the floor, crawling out improves your chance of survival.
- 02
Close doors behind you
Closing the doors you pass through slows down the smoke and flames following you.
- 03
Seal gaps with wet cloths
If you can’t get out, shut yourself in a room and block the gap under the door and other openings with wet cloths to keep smoke out.
- 04
Check which floor is burning
People on floors below the fire can usually get out. Above it, the stairwell carries smoke like a chimney; if it’s full of smoke, don’t try to go down.
- 05
Know the fire brigade is coming
The fire brigade will come. Wait without panicking, give your location to 112 and stay visible at a window.
With a fire on the 4th floor, the greatest risk is on floors 5–8
Devrim Akbal’s example: if the fire is on the 5th floor, people on the 1st, 2nd and 3rd floors can get out. But in an eight-storey building with a fire on the 4th floor, smoke rises and uses the stairwell like a chimney, so people on floors 5, 6, 7 and 8 face a very high risk from toxic smoke. On those floors, if the stairs are full of smoke, sheltering in a room and waiting for the fire brigade may be safer.
What belongs in an emergency bag
- Regular medication
- Some cash
- Credit cards
- Spare house and car keys
- Copies of ID and key documents
- Phone charger and torch
Tuğsavul says every home should have an emergency bag ready in advance; a family waiting for the fire brigade can check it in a few minutes.
“Because smoke gathers at the top, we have a better chance of breathing down low. So we need to crawl out.”
Yangın Kriminal note: Never go back for belongings
In the interview Tuğsavul says buildings can withstand even the worst fire for about 2 hours. In reality a building’s fire resistance varies widely with its type, height, use and permits; don’t rely on that figure in old, altered or unlicensed buildings. The emergency bag is packed before a fire; never go back into a smoky space for a bag, documents or belongings. If the way out is clear, get out first and think later.
When Is the OHS Specialist Liable? The “Scapegoat” Debate
The toughest part of the interview concerns OHS specialists detained in recent workplace-accident and fire cases. Tuğsavul argues that when the parties to a trial lack knowledge of fire and OHS, specialists can face the harshest measures before the Court of Cassation has even reviewed the case.
Four records that protect the specialist
The documents named in the interview that show a specialist did the job:
Written findings and recommendations
Identify the hazard on site and report it to the employer in writing; a verbal warning can’t be proven in court.
Entry in the approved logbook
Write findings and recommendations in the workplace’s officially approved logbook, with the date and a signature.
Notice to the authority
If a life-threatening hazard isn’t remedied, report it to the relevant authority.
Notarised notice
For critical or repeated warnings, serving notice through a notary strengthens its value as evidence.
Akbal’s view, from more than 2,000 expert reports: if the safety specialist warned, identified, reported and recorded the hazard, no fault remains; even where the job was done incompletely, the fault is at most secondary. Primary responsibility lies with whoever was obliged to take the measure.
“They don’t treat the specialist as innocent from the start. This comes from a lack of competence.”
Yangın Kriminal note: What Turkish law says
Under Article 4 of Türkiye’s Occupational Health and Safety Law No. 6331, an employer outsourcing OHS services is not relieved of its own responsibilities. Article 8 of the same law requires the safety specialist to report a life-threatening hazard to the employer in writing and, if no measure is taken, to the relevant unit of the Ministry. Who bears how much fault in a case is determined from the technical evidence and causation in that specific incident, which is why the specialist’s records are the backbone of the defence.
Related service:Fault and Liability AnalysisThe Sultanbeyli Factory Fire: A Mismanaged File
One of the cases that affected Tuğsavul most was a fire at a factory in Sultanbeyli, Istanbul, that killed two workers. The file shows how analytical thinking can change the course of a trial.
- 2 LIVES
Fire at the factory
Two workers died in a fire at a factory in Sultanbeyli.
- 15 YEARS
Employer and deputy on trial
The employer and the employer’s deputy faced up to 15 years’ heavy imprisonment. According to Tuğsavul, an expert witness, defence and prosecution who didn’t master the subject had brought the case to this point.
- REVIEW
The file is read again
When the file reached Tuğsavul, he saw it had been mismanaged and began an in-depth technical review.
- POWER LINE
The real fault lay elsewhere
The review showed the main fault lay not with the employer or the deputy but with the electricity distribution body that had failed to repair and correct the overhead power lines in the area.
Three lessons from the file
The rented diploma
According to Tuğsavul, electrical installations above a certain capacity must be handled by an electrical engineer, yet engineers rent out their diplomas and the work is done by a technician or a self-taught tradesman. The firm profits twice: from the lower wage and from the client.
Missing certificate, crowded file
In another case, someone who had given fire training put every certificate they had, scouting included, into the file, but not a fire-trainer certificate. Tuğsavul warns that there are people acting in bad faith who try to steer and deceive a trial.
Don’t trust a report blindly
Not every document “called an expert report” was prepared with enough expertise and care. Finding the culprit or clarifying an incident takes serious analytical thinking.
“You mustn’t put too much trust in expert reports. It’s called an expert report, but the panel’s expertise isn’t enough, or the necessary care isn’t taken.”
Tuğsavul’s proposal: Specialised adjudication
Tuğsavul believes the way past the problems of the expert-witness system is specialised arbitration or specialised courts, as in some other countries: a fire-related decision should be handled by a body specialising in occupational or fire safety. This is a view expressed in the interview; no such mechanism exists in current Turkish criminal procedure.
How to Write an Expert Report: Six Steps
An expert may not know everything, but for Tuğsavul one condition never changes: impartiality. After that comes disciplined reading of the file. An expert working without notes on a file of thousands of documents soon forgets what was read, starts over and writes a report that misses the spirit of the file.
Tuğsavul’s method
- 1
Read every document
Examine every document in the file, including those that seem unimportant. The critical detail is often on the most ordinary page.
- 2
List the documents on the first night
On the first night you receive the file, type up a list of what it contains.
- 3
Put events in chronological order
Arrange the documents by date and note how events unfolded. A piecemeal review lets the file go cold.
- 4
Digitise what you’ll need
Scan the documents you’ll refer to while writing so you have them in electronic form.
- 5
Find the rules in force on the date
What does the regulation require? If the incident happened in 2005, the regulation in force then applies, not today’s.
- 6
Doctrine, case law and earlier reports
What do legal scholarship and Court of Cassation precedents say? Has a report been prepared on a similar matter before? Check those too.
A portal of rated expert reports
Tuğsavul proposes a report portal where expert reports are uploaded. An expert writing a new report could follow earlier ones the way lawyers follow precedent. Each report would be rated, on both legal and technical grounds, by the three sides of a trial (prosecution, defence and court) and by universities as a fourth pillar. Readers could then see whether a report is reliable, ordinary, or just a document “called an expert report.”
The four pillars that would rate a report“If we work on a file without taking notes, we’re bound to forget it after a while.”
Yangın Kriminal note: A report must be verifiable
The shared conclusion of the interview: a good expert report must be verifiable and fit for trial; you should be able to trace how each finding led to each conclusion. In Türkiye expert witnessing is governed by Expert Witness Law No. 6754. In civil cases the parties may object to gaps and ambiguities in a report within two weeks of service (Code of Civil Procedure, Art. 281), and an independent expert opinion may be submitted under Art. 293 of the Code of Civil Procedure and Art. 67 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
Related service:Fire Report & Expert Witness OpinionOHS or Fire Safety? | The Türkiye Fire Education Model and Expert Witness Practice with Cihangir Tuğsavul
Class-A OHS specialist, chemical engineer and expert witness Cihangir Tuğsavul discusses how OHS and fire safety relate, the Türkiye Fire Education Model, panic and crawling out of a fire, the legal liability of OHS specialists, the Sultanbeyli factory fire case, how to write an expert report and what employers should do. (Interview in Turkish.)
What Should Employers Do? The Cheapest Service Isn’t the Right One
Shopping mall, factory, workshop, restaurant, car park or truck depot: whatever the business, Tuğsavul’s first message to employers is the same. The OHS and fire safety service you buy isn’t an expense; it’s your insurance.
Tuğsavul’s five pieces of advice for employers
Value the service properly
Different firms quote very different prices for the same job. A job has one fair price; the cheapest quote doesn’t mean the job will be done right.
Know that liability isn’t transferred
Even with the best consultancy, with not one but a thousand consultants, the employer is always responsible. The reports’ recommendations must be carried out.
Commission a third-eye audit
Have a second, independent specialist audit the work of the specialist you hired.
Sit in the front row at training
Employers should attend training before their staff, sit at the front and set the example.
Don’t shelve the report; plan
If every measure can’t be taken at once, prioritise and make a plan. Planning also weighs heavily in reducing criminal liability.
Who audits your consultant?
As an employer you pay a specialist, but is that specialist doing the job right? How far are they steering you right, and how well are they protecting you from mistakes? Tuğsavul’s proposal is to answer that with an audit report from a second, independent specialist. You then see clearly whether the work is right or wrong, incomplete or excessive, and whether the fee matches what you got. For employers new to the field especially, this brings both safety and peace of mind.
“Even with not one but a thousand consultants, the employer is always responsible.”
OHS and Expert-Witness Glossary
Short definitions of the key terms used in this guide:
- Occupational health and safety (OHS)
- Systematic, scientific work to reduce workplace accidents and occupational disease by removing hazards. In Türkiye it is governed by Law No. 6331.
- Class-A OHS specialist
- A safety specialist with the highest certificate class, qualified to work in all workplaces, including those in the very-hazardous category.
- Fire safety
- All measures aimed at preventing fire and minimising loss of life and property when one breaks out. For Tuğsavul it is an inseparable part of OHS.
- OSGB (joint health and safety unit)
- An authorised organisation in Türkiye that provides workplaces with safety specialists and workplace physicians.
- Psychosocial risk factors
- Factors such as stress, workload, bullying and fatigue that affect a worker’s mental health and attention and can set the stage for accidents.
- Emergency bag
- A bag packed in advance with what you’d need in a disaster or fire, such as medication, cash, cards, spare keys and document copies.
- Primary and secondary fault
- Primary fault is the decisive cause of the harm; secondary fault contributes to the outcome only to a lesser degree.
- Approved logbook
- The official book kept at a Turkish workplace where the safety specialist and workplace physician record findings and recommendations. One of the strongest proofs that the specialist did the job.
- Expert witness (bilirkişi)
- A specialist appointed by a prosecutor or court to give an opinion on a matter requiring special or technical knowledge. In Türkiye governed by Law No. 6754.
- Chronology (safahat)
- The stages of an incident or case file arranged in date order; the backbone of an expert review.
- Case law (içtihat)
- The body of higher-court decisions in similar cases that guides later rulings.
- Third-eye audit
- A review and report by a second, independent specialist on the work of the specialist or firm an employer has hired.
“If we take training in theory and in practice, true to its spirit and purpose, we’ll put out fires in crowded places better, with fewer lives and less property lost, because everyone will be an informed citizen.”
Frequently Asked Questions
Are occupational safety and fire safety the same thing?+
What is the Türkiye Fire Education Model?+
Why does fire safety training fail?+
Why should you crawl in a fire?+
What should you do first in an electrical fire at home?+
What should an emergency bag contain?+
Can an OHS specialist be held liable for a fire or workplace accident?+
Does hiring an OHS service free the employer from liability?+
What is a third-eye audit?+
How do you write an expert witness report?+
Can you challenge an expert report?+
Who is Cihangir Tuğsavul?+
Check Today: 8 Points
A list compiled from Tuğsavul’s warnings in the interview: half for your home and family, half for your workplace.
Cihangir Tuğsavul
Class-A occupational health and safety specialist (Istanbul Provincial Directorate of National Education), chemical engineer (Istanbul University) and expert witness in Istanbul’s courts. With 35 years of experience, he spent 27 years teaching, coordinated the MEGEP vocational education project, headed the OHS office of the Fatih District Directorate of National Education and has taught OHS at five universities. Author of “Chemical Risk Factors”; advisor to Yangın Kriminal.