Knowledge Base
Expert Insight Series · 09

Disaster Doesn’t Knock: The Fatal Mistakes People Make in Fires

Dialling the wrong number, waiting because “someone must have called”, installing a system and never testing it, leaving the phone on the charger all night… Abdullah Akıncı, who served 45 years and 8 months in the Istanbul Fire Department, once signed off 188 fires in a single day and now writes reports for the courts as an expert witness, explains with cases from the field the mistakes that turn fires into disasters.

Source: Expert interview with Abdullah Akıncı (Yangın Kriminal TV)Published by: Yangın KriminalPublished:

The 30-Second Summary

  • Fire is not fate. According to Abdullah Akıncı, a fire is a disaster born of negligence, ignorance and carelessness.
  • Call 112 first; don’t assume someone else has. A nightclub fire on Sıraselviler Street was reported by a single drunk caller; crews rescued at least 75 people.
  • Tell them how many people are inside. The fire brigade decides how many engines and crews to send based on that information.
  • A fire gets out of control in 3–4 minutes. Leave early if the escape route is clear; if smoke has filled the stairs, shut yourself in a room, seal the gap under the door with a wet towel and wait for the fire brigade.
  • An untested system is a useless system. The installer must test and hand over sprinklers, pumps and generators; the business must maintain them and staff must know how to use extinguishers.
  • Unplug the phone once it’s charged. Akıncı says 5–6 house fires a day in Istanbul start from chargers.
// SHORT ANSWER

Which Mistakes Turn Fires into Disasters?

[ Answer ]

The mistakes that turn fires into disasters are mostly made before the fire and in its first minutes: late or incomplete reporting, deciding to flee or to wait at the wrong moment, blocking escape routes and fire-engine access, never testing installed suppression systems, not training staff, and underestimating everyday risks such as chargers and cigarettes.

Abdullah Akıncı joined the Istanbul Fire Department at 19 and spent 30 of his 45 years and 8 months of service on the fireground itself. His observation is clear: behind major losses there is rarely one big mistake, but rather a chain of small acts of negligence.

That negligence is shared by everyone. Citizens call the wrong number or don’t call at all; business owners install systems only because the law requires it and never check whether they work; bystanders film while nobody looks for a blanket. In Akıncı’s words: “You can’t expect everything from the fire brigade.”

The second half of the interview is devoted to Akıncı’s current work, examining fire scenes as an expert witness: how the point of origin is read from glass, plaster and soot, why not every V-pattern marks where a fire started, and what the phrase “referred to the judicial authorities” in a fire department report really means.

  • 45 yrs 8 moAkıncı’s total service in the Istanbul Fire Department, 30 years of it on the fireground
  • 150–200Fires per day in Istanbul, according to Akıncı
  • 188Fires Akıncı signed off in a single day
  • 6–6.5 minYearly average response time to the scene (target: 5 min)
// REPORTING

Reporting a Fire: Who to Call and What to Say

One of the bleakest pictures Akıncı paints is that when the fire brigade is late, the cause is often not the brigade but the report. Some people dial the wrong number, some never call because “someone else surely has”, and some call but give the brigade nothing it can use.

When you call 112, say this, in this order

  1. 01The exact address

    Neighbourhood, street, building number and directions. If something is blocking vehicle access in a narrow street, say so.

  2. 02What is burning?

    A flat, a car, a rubbish container, a factory? The fire brigade sets off without seeing the fire; it decides what to send based on your description.

  3. 03How many people are inside?

    Is anyone trapped, how many, on which floor? According to Akıncı, this information can mean five engines are sent instead of three.

  4. 04What is inside?

    Gas cylinders, chemicals, flammable stock or production materials. Businesses should have someone ready to tell the brigade what is produced inside.

≈600False fire reports made to the fire brigade each year, according to Akıncı

A hoax call claiming “the hospital is burning” or “the hotel is burning” leaves no engines at the station. If a real fire breaks out at that moment, the brigade will be “late” again. The interview’s host suggests that hoax callers should be traced, reported to the prosecutor and face a deterrent penalty.

Yangın Kriminal note: 112, not 110

As Akıncı points out, the fire brigade’s number used to be 110. Today in Turkey, fire, ambulance and police calls are all taken by the 112 Emergency Call Centre. It is normal to hear “emergency centre” when you call 112; don’t hang up, the operator will transfer you to the fire brigade.

// RESPONSE

The Fire Brigade’s Golden Minutes: From Call to Scene

Every minute lost in a fire adds to its growth and to the closing of escape routes. Akıncı describes the times the fire brigade aims for after a call:

  1. 30 s

    Daytime: ignition on

    The moment the call comes in, crews board the engine and must have the ignition turned within 30 seconds during the day. If it’s lunchtime, lunch stays on the table.

  2. 60 s

    Night: ignition on

    For a crew woken in the middle of the night, the limit is 60 seconds.

  3. 3–4 min

    The fire gets out of control

    According to Akıncı, after 3–4 minutes a fire gets out of control and escape routes start to close.

  4. 5 min

    Target arrival time

    The fire brigade strives to reach the scene within the first 5 minutes after the call.

  5. 6–6.5 min

    Actual average

    Because of traffic, narrow streets and parked vehicles, the yearly average arrival time is around 6–6.5 minutes.

“A firefighter is counting his wages in the dormitory when the red light comes on; he throws the money aside and goes to the fire.”

Yangın Kriminal note: Why 3–4 minutes?

As a fire grows in a closed room, a layer of hot smoke builds up under the ceiling; at a certain temperature every combustible surface in the room can ignite at once. This sudden transition is called flashover, and in rooms furnished with modern materials it can occur within minutes. As an international reference, NFPA 1710 sets a turnout time of 80 seconds for fire calls and a travel time of 4 minutes for the first engine. That is why the times Akıncı gives matter.

Read the deep-dive:What Is Flashover in Fire Forensics?
// DURING A FIRE

During a Fire: Escape or Stay Put?

One of the points stressed most in the interview is the wrong decision made in panic. Fire and smoke travel upwards, so the floor the fire is on and the condition of the stairs decide what you should do. The principle that emerges from the interview: if the way out is safe, leave early; if not, shut yourself in and wait for the fire brigade.

GO

If the escape route is clear, leave now

  • If the fire is on an upper floor and you are below it, leave the building without delay
  • If the fire has just started and there is no smoke on the stairs, don’t wait; the route may close in 3–4 minutes
  • Close doors behind you as you leave and don’t use the lift
  • Once outside, tell the fire brigade whether anyone is still inside
STAY

If smoke has filled the stairs, shut yourself in

  • If the fire is below you and the stairs are full of smoke, don’t try to go down
  • Move into a room, close the door and put a wet towel along the gap underneath
  • If possible switch off the power at the main breaker and keep smoke out of the room
  • Call 112, give your exact location, stay visible at the window and don’t panic
From the field · Yeşilçam Street, Beyoğlu

A heavy truck, 200 metres of hose and 250 onlookers

Around 2:00–2:30 a.m., a three-storey building is burning on Yeşilçam Street, just off İstiklal Avenue. The engines must enter from Tarlabaşı Boulevard, but a heavy truck is parked across the street entrance. Small cars can pass; fire engines cannot. Two people are inside: one goes downstairs, the other goes out onto the balcony. While the fire is still young and he could still get down, he stays on the balcony. As crews advance by laying at least 200 metres of hose, the fire reaches the balcony and the man dies.

Don’t be a spectator, lend a hand

What upset Akıncı most was the 250–300 people gathered below, shouting “Don’t jump, the fire brigade is coming!” while filming videos and taking selfies. In his view, if someone had fetched a carpet or blanket from a neighbouring flat and ten people had held it taut, the man could have jumped from a low height and survived. Bystanders can do something too: report correctly, clear the way for the brigade and help when needed.

“Everyone in this battle is responsible for doing their part. You can’t expect everything from the fire brigade.”

Yangın Kriminal note: Jumping is a last resort

Jumping from a height, and trying to catch someone with a carpet or blanket, carries a serious risk of injury both for the person jumping and for those catching; it should only be considered from a low height, when flames and smoke have reached the person and no other way out remains. The priority is always to close the door and shelter from smoke, stay visible at the window and make the brigade’s arrival easier. Not parking across street entrances or in front of fire hydrants is part of that chain too.

// VIDEO · EXPERT INTERVIEW

Fatal Mistakes in Fires | Fire Expert Abdullah Akıncı

EXPERT INTERVIEW • ABDULLAH AKINCI
INTERVIEW • 40:55
29:00
40:55
85%
/// FIRE SCENE EXAMINATION — EXPERT INTERVIEW • ABDULLAH AKINCI

Fire expert and expert witness Abdullah Akıncı discusses his 45 years in the Istanbul Fire Department, wrong and false fire reports, turnout times, fatal mistakes made during fires, gaps in inspection and training at businesses, charger fires, determining the point of origin and the Gayrettepe nightclub fire. (Interview in Turkish.)

// FOR BUSINESSES

“No Fire Here in 30 Years”: The Fatal Mistakes Businesses Make

The sentence Akıncı heard most often while inspecting workplaces: “I’ve worked here for 30 years and never seen a fire.” Yet no one can know when a fire will break out. Fire protection is expensive; because employers don’t see it as an investment that produces output or profit, they either buy the cheapest, counterfeit equipment or take precautions only to meet legal obligations.

The four mistakes seen most often in the field

Cheap and counterfeit equipment

When fire safety is seen as a cost item, substandard and counterfeit equipment gets chosen. There is no guarantee it will work when a fire breaks out.

Systems installed but never tested

For Akıncı the most important issue is that nobody checks whether the safety measures actually work. Sprinklers, pumps and generators “exist” but have never been tried.

Staff who avoid training

He says staff at foreign companies are trained to a high standard, while at some local firms an employee called to use an extinguisher during a drill runs away saying “I’ll get dusty.” The employer offers training for free; the employee won’t take it.

Doors closed to the fire brigade

Doors marked “Authorised personnel only” are opened late to firefighters; nobody knows what is produced inside or who is trapped. Citizens and businesses need to inform the fire brigade.

Who tests the system, and who inspects it?

Having worked in the licensing department, Akıncı explains how responsibility is shared:

  1. The installer

    The company that installs the sprinklers, fire pump, generator or engine tests the system, commissions it and hands it over to the business. During the warranty period the responsibility is theirs.

  2. The fire brigade

    It checks, under Turkey’s Regulation on the Fire Protection of Buildings and according to the nature of the business, whether sprinklers, fire hose cabinets, manual call points and sirens are required, and looks at pump and engine capacity. Testing every day whether the system works is not the brigade’s job.

  3. The business

    Signing maintenance and inspection contracts, commissioning periodic tests and training staff are the business’s responsibility. Occupational safety companies or fire safety consultants can help.

Related service:Regulatory Compliance Analysis

“The door says “authorised personnel only”. There’s a fire, we arrive, and they open the door afterwards. You should have thought about this beforehand.”

// CAUSES OF FIRE

Why Do Fires Start? Cigarettes, Wiring and Chargers

For Akıncı, before examining a fire you need to know why fires start in the first place. He summarises the breakdown in Istanbul as follows:

  • 30–35%Fires caused by cigarettes
  • 20–25%Fires caused by electrical wiring
  • 5–6 / dayHouse fires in Istanbul started by chargers
The five main groups of fire causes
NegligenceForgetfulnessAccidentTechnical faultSabotage

Chargers: the “let it charge till morning” habit

Phone and charger fires fall into the technical-fault group. According to Akıncı, the biggest mistake is plugging the phone in at night and leaving it until morning: when a fire starts at night, everyone is asleep. A charger costs between 100 and 1,000 lira; a burnt home costs millions. If the fire spreads to a neighbour or a life is lost, the price can’t be measured in money.

  • Unplug the phone once it is full (the interview suggests at 95–96%)
  • Don’t charge it overnight, under a pillow or in bed
  • Don’t leave the charger plugged into the socket after charging
  • Don’t use crushed, hot or swollen batteries and cables

Yangın Kriminal note: Where is the real risk?

Charging adapters are designed to run on the 220-volt mains and convert it to the low voltage a phone needs, so plugging an adapter into a socket is not a mistake in itself. Fire records show that the real risks are non-standard and uncertified adapters, damaged cables, swollen or impact-damaged lithium batteries and places where heat can’t dissipate, such as beds and pillows. The claim Akıncı relays, that the electricity used by chargers left plugged in across Istanbul equals Erzurum’s annual consumption, comes from a scientific meeting and has not been verified by Yangın Kriminal.

// THE EXPERT WITNESS’S VIEW

The Expert Witness’s View: How Is a Fire’s Point of Origin Found?

For Akıncı the subject is “encyclopaedic”, enough for a whole library. Still, he sums up the basic principle: where a fire started, its centre reveals itself. The expert finds that centre by reading the following signs together:

  1. Heat and depth of burn

    Heat is greater where the fire started; materials have burned longer and deeper.

  2. Spalled plaster

    Where plaster has fallen from walls and ceilings points to the area where heat was most intense.

  3. Direction of broken glass

    The direction in which windows burst, the size of the fragments and the soot on the glass show the way to the fire’s centre.

  4. V-patterns, with care

    A V-shaped burn mark on a wall is valuable evidence; but, as Akıncı warns, not every V-pattern marks the fire’s centre.

90–95%Akıncı’s estimated chance of finding the point of origin if the debris has not been removed

The easy culprit: electricity

One of Akıncı’s most striking observations: “If fire investigators can’t find the cause of a fire, they blame electricity.” That is why preserving the debris and demonstrating the point of origin scientifically is decisive in both insurance and criminal files. Akıncı says an experienced expert can often sense at the scene whether a victim died in the fire or was killed and the fire staged, or whether someone pulled from water truly drowned; but he stresses that this is a matter for the judicial authorities, not the fire brigade.

Read the deep-dive:Electrical Arc: Cause or Effect?

What does “referred to the judicial authorities” mean?

The fire brigade does not write “suspicious” in its report. According to Akıncı, if the fire report ends with the phrase “referred to the judicial authorities”, the fire has been found suspicious. The file then goes to the prosecutor and the court, and an expert witness is appointed to examine it.

“If the debris at a fire scene isn’t removed, I can find where the fire started with 90–95 percent probability.”

// CASE FILES

From Gayrettepe to Hocapaşa: Major Cases and Istanbul’s Fire Towers

The incidents described in the interview repeat the same lessons from different angles: danger in front of the escape route, panic in an unfamiliar place, and the courage of firefighters.

Incidents described in the interview · Istanbul
  1. 29 LIVES

    Gayrettepe nightclub fire

    An incident Akıncı examined as an expert witness appointed by the prosecutor. To finish renovations within a month during Ramadan, the owner had carpenters, electricians and welders working at the same time; the fire started from welding work and polyurethane materials spread it rapidly. Because it began in front of the main door, those inside could not escape; darkness, panic and unfamiliarity with the premises increased the losses.

  2. 75 PEOPLE

    Sıraselviler nightclub

    In a fire reported only by a drunk caller, the fire brigade rescued at least 75 people trapped in a back garden.

  3. 3 FLOORS

    Bedridden woman in Küçükpazar

    Word came that a bedridden woman was still inside a three-storey building. On Akıncı’s order the crew went in without hesitation and brought her out; moments later the building collapsed completely.

  4. 1865

    The Hocapaşa fire

    Starting in Hocapaşa, Sirkeci, the fire, in Akıncı’s telling, reduced three-quarters of Istanbul to ashes. People took refuge from the smoke and flames in the Hasbahçe, today’s Gülhane Park, whose gates were opened for them. According to Akıncı, in that era a fire that started in Balat would end in Yedikule, and every great fire reshaped the city’s layout.

Istanbul’s fire watchtowers

Beyazıt Tower

According to Akıncı, a firefighter kept watch for years in the 162-step tower, for nostalgia’s sake. The tower was later handed over to Istanbul University.

Galata Tower

The Genoese-built tower was also used to watch for fires. Today it belongs to the Ministry of Culture and Tourism.

İcadiye Tower

The third tower, on the Üsküdar side. The district’s name survives, but the tower no longer stands.

/// When a fire was spotted from the towers, baskets or flags by day and lanterns by night signalled which district was burning.

// GLOSSARY

Fire Glossary

Short definitions of the key terms used in this guide:

112 Emergency Call Centre
The single number in Turkey that takes fire, ambulance and police calls. The old fire brigade number, 110, has been merged into it.
False report (hoax call)
A report of a fire or emergency that doesn’t exist. By tying up engines needlessly, it can delay the response to a real incident.
Turnout time
The time from receiving a call to the fire engine moving off. According to Akıncı, 30 seconds by day and 60 seconds at night.
Nomex
A flame- and heat-resistant aramid fibre used in firefighters’ turnout gear. The gear waits ready inside the engine.
Flashover
The moment heat built up in an enclosed space ignites every combustible surface in the room at once. Beyond this point survival in the room is almost impossible.
Sprinkler
An automatic suppression system that opens by itself at a set temperature and sprays water. It is useless unless the valve is open and the system is maintained.
Fire compartment
A section separated by walls, floors and doors so that fire and smoke cannot pass for a set time. Critical in hospitals for protecting patients who cannot be moved.
Regulation on the Fire Protection of Buildings
Turkey’s core legislation on the fire safety measures buildings must have. The fire brigade bases its licensing inspections on it.
Point of origin
Where the fire started. Found by assessing heat, spalled plaster, the direction of broken glass and burn marks together.
V-pattern
A V-shaped mark left on a wall as flames rise and spread. Valuable evidence, but not every V-pattern marks the point of origin.
“Referred to the judicial authorities”
The phrase in a fire department report indicating the fire was found suspicious. The file goes to the prosecutor and an expert examination begins.
Expert witness (bilirkişi)
A specialist appointed by the prosecutor or the court to give an opinion on a matter requiring technical knowledge.

“Fire is not a manifestation of our fate; it is a disaster born of our own negligence, ignorance and carelessness.”

Abdullah Akıncı · Fire Expert and Expert Witness

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the most common fatal mistakes people make in fires?+
According to Abdullah Akıncı, the deadliest mistakes are: calling the fire brigade late or not at all, not saying how many people are inside, waiting while the escape route is still open or trying to go down when smoke has filled the stairs, blocking escape routes and fire-engine access, not testing installed suppression systems and not training staff.
Which number do you call for the fire brigade in Turkey?+
In Turkey fires are reported to the 112 Emergency Call Centre. The old fire brigade number was 110. When you call 112 you reach the emergency call centre; don’t hang up, the operator passes your report to the fire brigade. Akıncı notes that dialling the wrong number and waiting because “someone else must have called” are major reasons the brigade arrives late.
What should you say when reporting a fire?+
The exact address and directions, what is burning (a flat, a car, a factory, etc.), how many people are inside and on which floor, and whether there are gas cylinders, chemicals or flammable materials inside. According to Akıncı, because the fire brigade sets off without seeing the fire, it decides how many engines to send based on this information.
In a fire, should I escape or stay where I am?+
If the escape route is safe, for example the fire is on an upper floor and you are below it, or the fire has just started and there is no smoke on the stairs, leave immediately. If the fire is below you and the stairs are full of smoke, don’t try to go down: move into a room, close the door, put a wet towel under it, cut the power if you can and call 112 to give your location. Akıncı says a fire gets out of control in 3–4 minutes, so the decision must be made early.
How quickly does the fire brigade set off after a call?+
According to Abdullah Akıncı, crews must be in the engine with the ignition on within 30 seconds by day and 60 seconds at night. The target is to reach the scene in 5 minutes; in Istanbul the yearly average arrival time is around 6–6.5 minutes.
Why are false fire reports dangerous?+
Akıncı says around 600 false reports are made to the fire brigade each year. A hoax “the hospital is on fire” call draws engines elsewhere; if a real fire breaks out at the same time, the brigade arrives late and lives are put at risk.
Who should test sprinklers and fire systems at a workplace?+
According to Akıncı, the installer tests and commissions the system before handing it over and is responsible during the warranty period. At the licensing stage the fire brigade checks which systems are required under the Regulation on the Fire Protection of Buildings and whether pump and engine capacity are adequate; keeping the system in working order is the business’s responsibility, through maintenance contracts, periodic tests and internal audits.
What is the most common cause of fires in Istanbul?+
According to Abdullah Akıncı, about 30–35% of fires in Istanbul are caused by cigarettes and 20–25% by electrical wiring. The rest involve household appliances, negligence and other causes. Fire causes are generally grouped as negligence, forgetfulness, accident, technical fault and sabotage.
Is it dangerous to leave a phone charging overnight?+
Akıncı says 5–6 house fires a day in Istanbul start from chargers and the biggest mistake is leaving the phone charging all night. Unplug it once full, don’t charge it in bed or under a pillow and don’t leave the charger in the socket. In Yangın Kriminal’s view, the real risks are non-standard adapters, damaged cables and swollen or impact-damaged batteries.
How is a fire’s point of origin determined?+
The expert assesses together the area with the greatest heat and deepest burning, spalled plaster on walls and ceilings, the direction in which windows burst, the size of the fragments and the soot on the glass. A V-pattern is also valuable evidence, but according to Akıncı not every V-pattern marks the fire’s centre. If the debris has not been removed, the point of origin can be found with 90–95% probability.
What does “referred to the judicial authorities” mean in a fire report?+
The fire brigade doesn’t write “suspicious” in its report. According to Akıncı, if the report ends with the phrase “referred to the judicial authorities”, the fire has been found suspicious; the file goes to the prosecutor and the court and an expert witness is appointed.
Who is Abdullah Akıncı?+
A fire expert and court-appointed expert witness. He joined the Istanbul Metropolitan Municipality Fire Department at 19 and spent 30 of his 45 years and 8 months of service on the fireground; he served as a chief in many units of the department, including training, response and licensing. He is an expert witness on the Istanbul Regional Expert Witness Board, has written reports on many incidents including the Gayrettepe nightclub fire in which 29 people died, and is a consultant to Yangın Kriminal.

Check Today: 8 Points

A list drawn from Akıncı’s warnings in the interview; half for your home and family, half for your workplace.

Does everyone at home know to call 112 in a fire and give the address and the number of people inside?
Are phones and other devices unplugged once charged, or charged overnight in bed?
Is anything blocking your building’s stairs or the street entrance that would stop the fire brigade?
Have you agreed which room you would shut yourselves in, and how, if a fire broke out below?
Have your sprinklers, pump and generator been tested since installation, and is there a maintenance contract?
Have your staff actually used an extinguisher in a drill?
Are emergency exits and stairs, including escalators, open at busy times?
Do you have someone responsible for telling the fire brigade what is produced inside and who is still there?

Abdullah Akıncı

Fire expert and expert witness. Served 45 years and 8 months in the Istanbul Fire Department, 30 of them on the fireground, and was a chief in many of its units, including training, response and licensing. As an expert witness on the Istanbul Regional Expert Witness Board he has written reports on many files, including the Gayrettepe nightclub fire, and is a consultant to Yangın Kriminal.

Fire Expert · Expert Witness · Former Fire Chief

/// This content is for general information and is based on an expert interview; it does not replace a fire risk assessment, expert witness report, expert opinion or legal advice for a specific building or incident. In an emergency, call 112.