From the Trace of a Fire to the Secret of a Signature: How Forensic Examination Works
Where and why did a fire start? Does the signature on a promissory note really belong to the person named? The two questions look unrelated, but they are answered the same way: the scientific examination of physical evidence. Forensic scientist Dr. Şahin İplikçi, who has investigated major Istanbul incidents from the Spice Bazaar explosion to the Haydarpaşa fire on assignment from the Chief Public Prosecutor, explains how soot is read at a fire scene, why samples go into steel containers, and how a forged signature is caught not by eye but by instruments and measurement.
Summary in 30 Seconds
- A fire is combustion that has escaped control. An explosion is an extremely rapid reaction that releases great energy and devastates its surroundings through gas pressure.
- "It was an electrical fault" needs proof. According to Dr. İplikçi, a fire’s cause is established not by eye or experience but by weighing soot patterns, samples and lab data together.
- The origin reveals itself through a V-pattern and whitening. Where a fire burned longest and hottest, the wall shows a V-shaped mark and whitened areas — a finding that must be backed by the lab.
- Samples go into steel containers. A plastic container can react with the sample depending on ambient heat and distort the result.
- Forged signatures and added digits are invisible to the eye. Infrared, ultraviolet, stereo and electron microscopes and digital imaging are used.
- Make it legible, leave no gap, check the back. Sign so your name can be read, leave no space between the text and your signature, and check the reverse of every page you sign.
What Is a Forensic Fire Examination?
A forensic fire examination establishes where, how and why a fire or explosion occurred through the scientific examination of physical evidence at the scene. Soot marks, burn patterns and properly collected solid, liquid and gas samples are analysed in the laboratory, and the conclusion is reported on the basis of all of these data together.
Dr. Şahin İplikçi defines "criminalistic" as reaching a conclusion about how an event occurred by scientifically examining the physical evidence. No single discipline is enough; chemistry, physics, materials science, electrical engineering and even meteorological data meet in the same case file.
That is why the sentence Dr. İplikçi stresses most is: "It is not right to say this started from an electrical short or from gas." Such a finding must be reasoned and grounded in scientific data. Nor is one lab result enough; the origin must be supported by several independent findings.
The same approach applies to the interview’s second subject, signature and handwriting examination: a forged signature or a zero added later is exposed not by eye, but with instruments and measurements.
- 3Pillars of a fire service: prevention, response and scene investigation
- 3Sample types collected at the scene: solid, liquid and gas
- 0.4–0.5 cmExample word-spacing measurement in forensic stylometry
What Is a Fire, What Is an Explosion? The Three Pillars of a Fire Service
For Dr. İplikçi, fire and explosion are highly specific, technical subjects. The first step of any examination is naming the event correctly.
Combustion that escapes control
Combustion we control is not a fire — think of a stove flame or a boiler. Combustion becomes a "fire" the moment it happens unintentionally and gets out of control. Fire usually spreads horizontally and vertically.
Sudden reaction, huge energy, gas pressure
An event that reacts extremely suddenly, releasing great energy and overturning and levelling its surroundings through the resulting gas pressure. Like fires, explosions come in many types.
The three pillars of a fire service
Fire is the fire service’s business. Dr. İplikçi groups its work into three main pillars:
01Fire prevention
Technical measures taken so that fire never starts. For Dr. İplikçi, what matters most is preventing fire from the outset by using technical data.
02Response
Firefighting and rescue: response tactics and techniques, equipment and trained personnel.
03Scene investigation
Examining the scene after a fire to investigate its cause from a forensic standpoint and report it with scientific data. This third pillar is Dr. İplikçi’s field.
/// The third pillar feeds the first two: every correctly identified fire cause becomes data for preventing the next fire.
6 Steps at a Fire Scene: From the Line of Business to the Lab
Dr. İplikçi compares a fire scene examination to an autopsy in forensic medicine: specific methods are applied in a specific order. But first of all, you have to understand the anatomy of the fire.
01 · Learn the Line of Business
What was done on the premises defines the character of the fire
02 · Read the Fire’s Anatomy
Fire spreads horizontally and vertically; the type of combustion is identified
03 · The Soot Method
The shape, direction and colour of soot on the walls are read
04 · Point of Origin
Look for a V-pattern and whitening where it burned longest and hottest
05 · Collect Samples
Solid, liquid and gas samples are collected by the book and placed in steel containers
06 · Lab and Multiple Data
Field findings are assessed in parallel with laboratory results
Result: No Verdict on a Single Data Point
According to Dr. İplikçi, looking at one lab result and saying "it started from this" is wrong. The origin, cause, growth, spread and fault can only be established when all findings are assessed together and run technically in parallel.
What Happens in the Lab? Chromatography, Electron Microscopy and Meteorology
Samples collected at the scene become scientific data in the laboratory. The main methods Dr. İplikçi lists in the interview:
Gas chromatography
Liquid samples are analysed to determine whether they contain chemicals. Thin-layer chromatography and similar tests can reveal whether explosives were used; high-performance chromatography systems are used for more sensitive analyses.
Electron microscope
The micro-crystalline structure of copper in electrical cables is examined. This provides data on whether the damage came from an electrical fault or from a fire arriving from outside. For Dr. İplikçi this cannot be settled by eye or experience.
Meteorology and other data
Meteorological data such as wind, temperature and humidity are added to the file to explain how the fire spread. A forensic examination draws on many sciences at once.
Copper microstructure: internal or external cause?
Dr. İplikçi notes that the FBI in the US and the Bundeskriminalamt in Germany perform this analysis with electron microscopes, and that in Türkiye it can be done at the Council of Forensic Medicine and the Police and Gendarmerie criminal laboratories. The difference is read mainly through colour tones and the colour sequences seen under the microscope:
Overload or short circuit
- Damage began inside the conductor, driven by current
- As the host recalls it, the crystal structure shows a scattered, disordered arrangement
- Characteristic colour tones and sequences appear under the microscope
Fire spreading from outside
- The cable was attacked by flame after surrounding materials caught fire
- As the host recalls it, the crystals remain ordered, lined up side by side
- The colour sequence differs from internal damage; an experienced expert reports the distinction
Yangın Kriminal note: The microscope does not decide alone
Microscopic examination of melting on copper is valuable data, but international fire-investigation practice (NFPA 921) acknowledges that metallurgical findings alone may not reliably distinguish an arc that caused a fire from one the fire caused. That is why microscope results are assessed together with arc mapping, scene patterns and witness statements — exactly what Dr. İplikçi means by "supporting the finding with many data."
Read the deep dive:Electrical Arc: Cause or Effect?Forensic Fire Examination & Forged Signature Detection | Dr. Şahin İplikçi
Forensic scientist Dr. Şahin İplikçi explains the definitions of fire and explosion, finding the point of origin with the soot method and V-patterns, sample collection and laboratory analysis, his work on major Istanbul incidents, detecting forged signatures and handwriting, forensic stylometry, and fire-safety warnings for businesses. (Interview in Turkish.)
From the Spice Bazaar to Haydarpaşa: Major Cases and Fire-Service Years
Every Istanbul incident Dr. İplikçi worked on was examined in detail on assignment from the Chief Public Prosecutor, with causes established through scientific data. The examples he lists in the interview:
- 1998
Spice Bazaar explosion
A major explosion in the historic bazaar — the first big case Dr. İplikçi mentions.
- 2003
Synagogue and HSBC bombings
The 2003 bomb attacks in Istanbul on a synagogue and the HSBC building.
- 2003
British Consulate-General
The explosion at the British Consulate-General in the same period.
- 2010
Haydarpaşa Station fire
The fire that engulfed the roof of the historic Haydarpaşa railway station.
Fire-service years
Acting Fire Chief
Dr. İplikçi served as Acting Fire Chief at the Istanbul Metropolitan Municipality. He recalls that the mayor of the time was meticulous about fire, followed incidents closely and asked many questions.
Rescue helicopter project
With support from business people, he developed a project to give the fire service a rescue helicopter. The goal was to rescue people before they died or were injured; the project could not be realised for various reasons.
A call for equal equipment
The Istanbul Fire Department is equipped with top-level rescue technology, including thermal cameras. But according to Dr. İplikçi, such technology is hard to find in eastern provinces such as Bingöl; equipment should be distributed equally across Türkiye.
How Are Forged Signatures and Handwriting Detected?
Dr. İplikçi’s second field, in which he earned a master’s degree at the Institute of Forensic Medicine, is the forensic examination of signatures and handwriting. He says signature and handwriting forgery is very common today, especially on cheques and promissory notes, where it creates legal consequences and serious risk.
How does 10 million become 100 million?
Dr. İplikçi’s example: a note says 10 million; someone adds a zero at the end with the same pen and the amount becomes 100 million. Or one digit is turned into another. Because the same pen is used, these additions cannot be seen with the naked eye.
Instruments used
The document is examined with these instruments and the images are transferred to digital media. Ink differences, additions and line crossings become visible as shapes, and the report is supported with visual evidence.
A signature open to forgery
- A single straight line or a simple shape like a bird
- A signature in which no letter of the name can be read
- A wide gap left between the text and the signature
- Signing a page without checking its reverse side
The signature Dr. İplikçi recommends
- A personal signature in which the first and last name can be read
- Signing directly below the text, without leaving a gap
- Checking the back of the page before signing
- Reviewing once whether your signing habit is legally sound
Yangın Kriminal note: What does Turkish law say?
Dr. İplikçi bases the need for a legible name on the Turkish Commercial Code and Code of Obligations. The Code of Obligations (TBK art. 15) requires the signature to be in the obligor’s own handwriting; legibility is not written into the law as a separate validity condition. Even so, a legible, personal signature is harder to imitate and strengthens the comparison examination if it is ever disputed.
Related service:Forensic Document ExaminationForensic Stylometry: Can Handwriting’s Fingerprint Be Measured?
For Dr. İplikçi, everyone’s handwriting has unique features, just like DNA or a fingerprint. Forensic stylometry turns those features into data through mathematical measurement:
Spacing between words and sentences
Everyone leaves a characteristic distance between words, sentences and punctuation marks. Averaging these distances yields a measure specific to that person.
Upper- to lower-case ratio
A person’s use of capital and small letters, and the ratio between them, is an important datum for telling writers apart.
Angle to the horizontal
The angle that lines and letters make with the horizontal is measured; slant varies from person to person.
Word choice
The words used and how often also provide data. Dr. İplikçi’s example: the Turkish word "hububat" (cereals) is generally used by people over 50 and is unlikely from someone aged 20–30 — offering clues to the writer’s age and education.
“When you use mathematics within science, it is indisputable; whether that person wrote the text or not can be revealed.”
/// Stylometric measurements are not used alone but together with graphological comparison against known signatures and handwriting.
Nobody Knows Everything: What Should Businesses Do About Fire?
Dr. İplikçi’s message to business people is clear: you do not have to know about fire, but you do have to consult someone who does. Otherwise systems get installed but fail when the fire comes.
Don’t disable the system with your own hands
Closing the valve before the holiday
"We’re off for the holiday, there’s a water leak, we shut it; we’ll repair it later." In a fire that starts while the suppression system’s water is off, the system is useless.
Switching off the generator and system
As the host describes, some facilities chain and padlock valves and generators so that nobody can shut them — because someone may switch them off, saying "I turned it on."
Padlocking the fire escape
Dr. İplikçi’s example: a hotel builds a flawless fire escape, then puts a lock on its door to keep burglars out. "I’ll leave the interpretation to you."
Equipment no one can use in a panic
Having equipment is not enough. If devices cannot be used in a panic, or do not work, even the most expensive system is worthless.
Whom to consult?
The fire department
Get the local fire department’s opinion before installing sprinklers or a fixed suppression system.
Competent firms and consultants
Work with qualified specialist companies when choosing and installing a system.
Trained staff
Train staff in-house; fire psychology, response under panic and evacuation techniques can all be learned.
“Nobody knows everything. A business owner should consult the fire department, consult serious companies, or rely on staff they have trained. Otherwise there will be trouble.”
Forensic Examination Glossary
Short definitions of the key terms used in this guide:
- Forensic examination (criminalistics)
- Reaching a conclusion about how an event occurred by examining physical evidence with scientific methods. It draws on chemistry, physics, materials science, electrical engineering and more.
- Fire
- Combustion that occurs unintentionally and has escaped control.
- Explosion
- An event in which an extremely rapid reaction releases great energy and destroys its surroundings through gas pressure.
- Point of origin
- The place where a fire started. The cause can only be explained reliably once the origin has been correctly identified.
- V-pattern
- A V-shaped burn mark on a wall left by rising, spreading flame. Its base often points to the area where the fire began.
- Whitening (clean burn)
- A wall turning pale where long, intense burning has burned off the soot layer. It can indicate that the area burned more than its surroundings.
- Soot method
- Reading flame movement and fire development from the shape, direction and colour of soot deposits on walls.
- Gas chromatography
- An analytical method that separates and identifies a sample’s chemical components. In fire debris it looks for ignitable liquids and chemical residues.
- Thin-layer chromatography
- A quick chromatography test that separates components on a thin layer. It can be used to screen for explosive residues.
- Electron microscope
- A microscope that images surfaces at very high magnification. Used to examine the microstructure of copper conductors and line details on documents.
- Graphology (signature and handwriting examination)
- Forensic examination of whom a signature or handwriting belongs to and whether additions or alterations were made.
- Forensic stylometry
- Mathematically measuring features such as word spacing, letter ratios, slant and word choice to identify a writer.
“It is not right to say this started from an electrical short or from gas. It has to be reasoned; it has to rest on scientific data.”
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a forensic fire examination?+
What is the difference between a fire and an explosion?+
How is the point of origin of a fire found?+
What samples are taken at a fire scene?+
Why are fire samples placed in steel rather than plastic containers?+
How can you tell whether a fire came from an electrical fault or from outside?+
How is a forged signature detected?+
What is forensic stylometry?+
How do you sign safely?+
Is a legible signature legally required in Türkiye?+
What lesson should be drawn from the Bolu Kartalkaya hotel fire?+
Who is Dr. Şahin İplikçi?+
Check Today: 8 Points
A list compiled from Dr. İplikçi’s warnings in the interview — half for your signature, half for your premises.
Dr. Şahin İplikçi
Forensic scientist. He earned a doctorate on the forensic aspects of fire and a master’s degree on the forensic examination of signatures and handwriting at the Institute of Forensic Medicine. He has investigated many major incidents on assignment from the Chief Public Prosecutor, including the Spice Bazaar explosion, the 2003 Istanbul bombings and the Haydarpaşa Station fire, and served as Acting Fire Chief at the Istanbul Metropolitan Municipality.