Knowledge Base
Expert Insight Series · 07

Was the Fire Electrical? Arc Beads, Lithium Batteries and Electric Vehicles

Roughly 40% of fires are electrical in origin. But how do you tell whether a fire started in a cable, or reached the cable from somewhere else? Naci Çetinkaya, an electrical-electronics engineer from METU (ODTÜ) and a registered expert witness with the Istanbul Regional Board of Expert Witnesses, looks for the answer on the conductors themselves: arc beads. He also explains how thermal cameras catch loose connections, why lithium batteries ignite while charging, and how a hybrid yacht fire at Kalamış Marina spread to three more boats.

Source: Expert interview with Naci Çetinkaya (Yangın Kriminal TV)Publisher: Yangın KriminalPublished:

The 30-Second Summary

  • Around 40% of fires are electrical. According to Çetinkaya, the main culprit is insulation failure, driven by overload, incorrectly sized cables and loads added over time.
  • The signature of an electrical fire is the arc bead. When conductors touch and arc, they leave melted beads on their ends that look like roasted chickpeas. In an external fire the insulation may burn away, but the conductors stay apart and no beads form.
  • Loose connections are a silent ignition source. Joints and terminals loosen as they heat and cool, so they should be scanned with a thermal camera every 6 months.
  • Lithium batteries ignite most often while charging. If overheating turns into thermal runaway, the battery burns while releasing flammable gases, and the fire is extremely hard to put out.
  • Keep your distance from EVs. Çetinkaya recommends parking at least 2 metres from an electric vehicle and keeping EVs out of enclosed garages that lack a dedicated suppression system.
  • Measure at least once a year. Thermal imaging and tightness checks on low-voltage panels, earthing measurements and a working residual-current device are the core safeguards.
// SHORT ANSWER

How Can You Tell If a Fire Was Electrical?

[ Answer ]

By examining the conductors of the cables at the scene. If the fire was electrical, the conductors touched once their insulation melted, an arc formed and melted metal beads remain at the point of contact. If the fire came from outside and burned the cables later, the insulation may be gone but the conductors are still separated, with no contact and no beading.

Naci Çetinkaya says that when he arrives at a fire scene as an expert witness, his first task is to find beading and where it is located. Beads show that the conductors made contact while current was flowing. Where the bead sits gives a clue to where the fire began.

Cable insulation burns away completely in a fire, leaving only the copper or aluminium conductor. That makes the position of the conductors relative to each other, and the melting marks on them, the most valuable evidence an expert has. Where necessary, samples are examined with laboratory methods such as scanning electron microscopy (SEM).

The interview’s second message is prevention: most electrical fires start with overload and loose connections, and both can be seen with a thermal camera months before a fire.

  • ~40%Share of fires that are electrical, according to Çetinkaya
  • 6 monthsRecommended interval for thermal-camera scans of connections
  • 2 mRecommended minimum distance when parking next to an EV
// FORENSIC EXAMINATION

Arc Beads: Electrical Origin or External Fire?

The expert’s question is simple: did the cable start the fire, or did the fire burn the cable? The two scenarios leave different marks on the conductors.

ELECTRICAL ORIGIN

The cable started the fire

  • Insulation melted from excessive heat and the conductors touched
  • An arc formed at the contact point; round, melted beads sit on the conductor ends
  • Melting is localised: the conductor right next to the bead can look intact
  • The bead’s location can point to the area where the fire began
EXTERNAL FIRE

The fire burned the cable later

  • Flames arrived from outside (textiles, furniture, a match, vegetation…) and burned the insulation
  • The conductors stayed apart; the phases never touched
  • No arc beads; any melting is spread out, with drip-like run marks
  • The cables were not the cause, just one of the items the fire consumed

What does the laboratory look for?

When visual examination is not enough, or the parties dispute the findings, samples go to the laboratory. The methods highlighted in the interview:

Scanning electron microscopy (SEM)

The bead’s surface and internal structure are examined at very high magnification. Metal melted by an arc and metal melted by flames show different structures, which helps separate arc beads from fire-melted beads. It is done in university laboratories and requires a separate budget.

Arc or flame?Metal structureUniversity lab

Mass spectrometry and chromatography

Searches fire debris for traces of accelerants such as thinner, solvent, petrol or kerosene, or of substances such as paraffin and candle wax. Used in cases with suspected arson or sabotage to support or refute an electrical claim.

Accelerant detectionSuspected sabotageGC-MS

Scene documentation

Which circuit each cable belonged to, the state of the fuses and residual-current devices and the position of the beads are photographed and drawn on a sketch. A lab result only means something if the sample was properly documented.

Circuit tracingFuse stateScene sketch

Yangın Kriminal note: one bead is not enough

An arc bead shows that the circuit was energised when it was damaged. But a fire that starts elsewhere can also cause arcing when it attacks an energised cable. That is why international fire investigation practice (NFPA 921) relies not on a single bead but on arc mapping: every arc site across all circuits is marked, and the investigator looks for the earliest arc closest to the source. That is exactly what Çetinkaya means by "the location of the bead".

Go deeper:Electrical Arc: Cause or Effect?
// FIRE CHAIN

From Overload to Ignition: The 5 Steps of an Electrical Fire

The mechanism Çetinkaya describes is not a single fault but neglect that builds up over time. Each link makes the next one possible:

01 · Load and Cable Size

Cables are sized to run at 70–80% of capacity for the load; new loads upset that balance

Added loadsWrong cable sizeExtra lines

02 · Thermal Loosening

Joints and terminals loosen as they heat and cool

Thermal expansionLoose terminalContact resistance

03 · Overheating

The loose point and the overloaded cable heat up continuously

Hot spotDiscolourationBurning smell

04 · Insulation Failure

The insulation melts or strips away; conductors touch

Ageing insulationShort circuit

05 · Arc and Ignition

Arc heat ignites nearby combustibles and leaves a bead behind

Arc beadCombustiblesFire origin

Result: A Fire You Could Have Seen Coming

The first three links can be seen with a thermal camera months before any fire. The last link is the evidence the expert finds on the conductors afterwards: the arc bead.

/// The chain is compiled from the interview. The thermal-imaging interval is Çetinkaya’s recommendation; the exact maintenance schedule should be set by an engineer based on the size and load of the facility.
// VIDEO · EXPERT INTERVIEW

Why Do Electric Vehicles Catch Fire? Electrical Fires with Naci Çetinkaya

EXPERT INTERVIEW • NACİ ÇETİNKAYA
INTERVIEW • 19:04
00:00
19:04
85%
/// INTERVIEW START — EXPERT INTERVIEW • NACİ ÇETİNKAYA

Electrical-electronics engineer and expert witness Naci Çetinkaya discusses the causes of electrical fires, how arc beads identify an electrical origin, lithium battery and EV fires, the hybrid yacht fire at Kalamış Marina and periodic inspection advice for businesses. (Interview in Turkish.)

// LITHIUM BATTERIES

Why Do Electric Vehicles and Lithium Batteries Catch Fire?

According to Çetinkaya, lithium batteries are extremely sensitive to heat. The moment they cannot shed the heat produced while charging, they begin heating themselves and can go as far as exploding. Phone, scooter, boat or car, the mechanism is the same; only the amount of energy changes.

The riskiest moment: charging

EV fires most often start during charging, at the connector or in an overheating battery. Charging is when the battery produces the most heat and, often, when nobody is around.

Thermal runaway

Overheating that starts in one cell spreads to its neighbours in a chain reaction. The battery releases flammable gases, including hydrogen, and burns at very high temperatures; the fire feeds itself.

Hard to extinguish

According to Çetinkaya, a battery fire that has started is nearly impossible to put out and often lasts until the vehicle has burned out. In an enclosed garage without suitable equipment, that puts the whole building at risk.

5 precautions for owners and building managers

  1. 1

    Keep your distance

    Leave at least 2 metres when parking next to an electric vehicle; it slows a possible fire from spreading.

  2. 2

    Question the enclosed garage

    Decide at management level whether EVs should be allowed into enclosed garages that have no dedicated suppression and detection system. The management of Çetinkaya’s own residential complex has decided against it.

  3. 3

    Don’t leave charging unattended

    Supply the charger from a suitable, dedicated circuit, and during long charging sessions check whether the connector and cable are overheating.

  4. 4

    Read the manual

    Find out whether the charging system cuts off on overcharge or only gives a warning. The Kalamış case came from exactly this gap in knowledge.

  5. 5

    Don’t charge a damaged battery

    Have a battery that has taken a hit, is swollen or heats abnormally checked by an authorised service before charging it.

If LPG cars are kept out, why not EVs?

The current situation

According to Çetinkaya, there is no specific regulation on EVs entering enclosed car parks in Türkiye. Even so, charging stations are being installed in the enclosed car parks of shopping malls.

The expert’s view

If LPG vehicles cannot enter enclosed garages, then until the extinguishing problem is solved, EVs should only be admitted to garages fitted with a dedicated suppression system.

/// This is the expert’s personal view; for car parks and charging stations, the fire regulations in force and the local fire brigade’s opinion take precedence.

// CASE FILE

Kalamış Marina: Thermal Runaway on a One-Month-Old Hybrid Boat

This case, on which Çetinkaya recently wrote a report, shows that battery risk is not limited to cars.

Case file · Kalamış Marina, Istanbul

A boat that ran on both electricity and diesel

  1. 01 · Battery bank on charge

    The hybrid boat carries a large battery bank for electric running. Planning to set off before dawn, the crew plug the batteries in and go to sleep.

  2. 02 · Overcharging

    The charging system does not cut off on overcharge; it only gives an audible and visual alarm. The sleeping crew never notice it.

  3. 03 · Thermal runaway

    The overheated batteries go into thermal runaway, explode and start to burn.

  4. 04 · Spread

    The fire spreads to three neighbouring boats in the marina. The one-month-old boat burns to ashes.

  • ~€300,000Total damage
  • 4 boatsAffected by the fire
  • 1 monthAge of the boat

Lessons from the file

  • When buying, find out whether the charging system cuts off automatically on overcharge.
  • Read the user manual before the first trip; an alarm only helps if you know what it means.
  • Don’t leave a battery bank on long, unattended charges; consider an extra cut-off protection.
  • Have an authorised service check the battery compartment’s ventilation and heat and smoke detection.
// PERIODIC INSPECTION

What Should Businesses Do? Thermal Imaging, Earthing and RCDs

Home, workplace, restaurant or hotel, Çetinkaya’s advice is the same: don’t check with a voltage-tester screwdriver on your own, but by measuring, with a qualified engineer. Regulations only make annual maintenance mandatory for transformers, yet most of the risk lies in the low-voltage installation downstream of the transformer.

Legal requirementOnce a year

Transformer maintenance

The routine maintenance required by regulation. Even with a well-kept transformer, the installation after it must be checked separately.

Expert recommendation1–2 times a year

Thermal imaging and tightness checks

Low-voltage panels, connection points and joints are scanned with a thermal camera and hot spots are tightened. Every connection that carries overcurrent loosens over time.

Expert recommendationAt least yearly

Earthing measurement

As new buildings go up nearby, soil conditions and earthing resistance can change. Çetinkaya says this measurement must be done without fail.

Expert recommendationAlways + test

Residual-current device

A relay that opens the circuit when there is an insulation fault. It should always be installed, with a verified earthing system, and tested regularly with its test button.

A fire warns you first: 5 warning signs

As the host reminds us, people who live or work in a space usually sense when something is wrong. If you notice any of these signs, have an electrical engineer look at it without delay:

  1. 1

    Warm cable, socket or panel

    A socket, plug or panel cover that feels warm or hot to the touch is a sign of overload or a loose connection.

  2. 2

    Crackling or buzzing

    Crackling from a panel or socket can mean arcing or a loose contact.

  3. 3

    Smell of burning plastic

    Overheating insulation gives off a distinctive smell; don’t dismiss it until you have found the source.

  4. 4

    Discolouration and soot

    Darkening around a socket, a melted plug or a discoloured cable sheath is evidence of past overheating.

  5. 5

    A breaker that keeps tripping

    Frequent tripping shows the circuit is carrying more than it can handle; fitting a bigger breaker is not the fix.

“Over time, as overcurrent flows, connection points will loosen, and every one of those loose points can become a source of fire later on.”

// GLOSSARY

Electrical Fire Investigation Glossary

Short definitions of the key terms used in this guide:

Arc bead (beading)
A mark formed when metal melts at the point where two energised conductors touch and arc, then solidifies as a round droplet. The most important physical evidence of an electrical fire.
Arc mapping
Marking every arc site across all circuits at a fire scene and plotting them on a sketch, used to narrow down the area of origin.
Insulation failure
When the insulation around a conductor stops working because of heat, ageing or mechanical damage. The main cause of short circuits and leakage current.
Cable cross-section
The conductor’s cross-sectional area in mm², which sets the current it can carry. According to Çetinkaya, cables are chosen to run at 70–80% of capacity.
Thermal loosening
Connection points expanding and contracting as they heat and cool, and loosening over time; it raises contact resistance and heating.
Thermal camera
A camera that images surface temperatures. It reveals loose and overheating connections in panels before a fire starts.
Thermal runaway
Self-sustaining overheating in a lithium cell that spreads to neighbouring cells, causing flammable gas release, explosion and a fire that is hard to put out.
Battery bank
A group of interconnected batteries on boats and in energy-storage systems. Because it stores a lot of energy, charge control is critical.
Residual-current device (RCD)
A protective device that detects a current imbalance between phase and neutral and cuts the circuit. 30 mA types protect people; 300 mA types protect against fire.
Earthing
Safely diverting unwanted voltage in an installation to the ground. An unmeasured earthing system also puts the correct operation of the RCD at risk.
SEM (scanning electron microscope)
A microscope that images surfaces at very high magnification. In fire investigation it helps tell whether a bead was formed by an arc or by the fire’s heat.
GC-MS
Gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. Finds traces of accelerants such as petrol, thinner or kerosene in fire debris.

“If it is electrical, there will be beading. Even if an external fire melts the cable insulation, there will be a gap between the conductors; they will not have touched.”

Naci Çetinkaya · Electrical-Electronics Engineer and Expert Witness

Frequently Asked Questions

How can you tell if a fire was electrical?+
The expert looks for arc beads on the conductors of the cables at the scene. In an electrical fire, the conductors touch once their insulation melts, an arc forms and round, melted beads remain at the contact point. In an external fire, the insulation may burn away but the conductors stay apart and no beads appear.
What is an arc bead?+
When two current-carrying conductors touch, the resulting arc melts the metal, which solidifies on the conductor end as a round droplet. The interview’s host compares it to a roasted chickpea. It shows the circuit was energised at the moment of damage.
What do cables look like after an external fire?+
The insulation may be completely burned away, but the conductors have not touched and no arc beads have formed. According to Naci Çetinkaya, this shows the fire came from outside, not from the electrical system, and the cables were simply among the items it burned.
Does a single arc bead prove a fire was electrical?+
Not on its own. A fire that starts elsewhere can also cause arcing when it attacks an energised cable. That is why investigators use arc mapping: all arc sites are marked and the earliest arc closest to the source is identified. If needed, the bead is examined with SEM to tell arc melting from fire melting.
What is the most common cause of electrical fires?+
According to Naci Çetinkaya, the biggest problem is insulation failure. Behind it lie overload, cables not sized correctly for the load, new loads added over time and joints that loosen as they heat and cool.
How often should an electrical installation be checked with a thermal camera?+
Çetinkaya recommends scanning connection points with a thermal camera and checking their tightness every 6 months, that is once or twice a year. Although regulations only require annual transformer maintenance, low-voltage panels should be measured regularly too.
Why do electric vehicles catch fire?+
Lithium-ion batteries are very sensitive to heat. A battery that cannot shed the heat produced while charging can go into thermal runaway: cells heat up in a chain, flammable gases are released and the fire feeds itself. According to Çetinkaya, EV fires most often start during charging, at the connector and in an overheating battery.
Should electric vehicles be allowed into enclosed car parks?+
Naci Çetinkaya’s view is that, until the extinguishing problem is solved, EVs should only be admitted to enclosed garages fitted with a dedicated suppression system. He points to the restriction already applied to LPG vehicles and recommends staying at least 2 metres from an EV when parking. The fire regulations in force always take precedence.
Why are lithium battery fires so hard to put out?+
During thermal runaway the battery produces its own heat and flammable gases, including hydrogen, so the source feeding the fire is inside the battery. According to Çetinkaya, a vehicle battery fire that has started often lasts until the car has burned out. That makes prevention, meaning controlled charging, far more important than extinguishing.
How did the yacht fire at Kalamış Marina start?+
The battery bank of a one-month-old hybrid boat, running on both electricity and diesel, was left charging overnight. The charging system did not cut off on overcharge; it only gave an audible and visual alarm. The overheated batteries went into thermal runaway and exploded, the fire spread to three neighbouring boats and the damage came to around €300,000.
Why do RCDs and earthing matter?+
A residual-current device opens the circuit when there is an insulation fault, protecting against both electric shock and fire, but it depends on a sound earthing system to work properly. Because nearby construction can change soil conditions, Çetinkaya recommends measuring earthing at least once a year.

Check Today: 8 Points

A list compiled from Çetinkaya’s recommendations; most items become clear quickly with an engineer’s site visit.

When was your last thermal-camera scan? Has the tightness of the panel connections been checked?
Have cable sizes been recalculated for equipment added to the installation later?
Is any socket, plug, junction box or panel cover warm?
Has earthing been measured within the past year?
Is there a residual-current device in the installation, and is its test button tried regularly?
Is your transformer maintenance up to date?
Are your EV, scooter or boat batteries left on long, unattended charges?
Does your charging system cut off on overcharge, or does it only give a warning?

Naci Çetinkaya

Electrical-electronics engineer. He graduated from METU (ODTÜ) in 1989 and went straight into industry. For the past 8 years he has served as an active expert witness registered with the Istanbul Regional Board of Expert Witnesses.

Electrical-Electronics Engineer · Expert Witness

/// This content is for general information and is based on an expert interview; it does not replace an electrical design, an expert report, laboratory analysis or legal advice for a specific facility or case. In an emergency, call 112.