Institutionalization and Financial Control in Family Businesses: Cash Flow, Authority and the Family Constitution
From the outside it looks like a giant company; step inside and there is no daily cash report, no budget, all authority sits with one person and there is no control at all… Chartered accountant and independent auditor Nuri Kuşçu, who opened his first office in Bakırköy in 1995, served as general manager and CFO in large company groups and today examines company files as a court expert, trustee and concordat commissioner, explains why family businesses fail to institutionalize and how to build financial control.
The 30-Second Summary
- Institutionalization means a company is run by rules, not by one person. Finance, accounting, purchasing, sales and marketing, production and HR should be separate units, each led by a professional who truly knows the job.
- In family businesses the process is painful. According to Kuşçu, the founding generation that started with two machines and grew through its own labour struggles to let go of control; the company looks like a giant outside and stays a small shop inside.
- Financial control starts with a daily cash-flow table. A cash report processed every day forces timely bookkeeping and feeds weekly, monthly and quarterly cash plans and the budget.
- The budget is prepared in December; the balance sheet is produced every month. Unit budgets are consolidated and submitted for board approval; the monthly balance sheet and income statement answer “Where are we, where are we going?”
- A manager without authority is nothing; authority without control is a loss. Job descriptions and signing authority must be clearly defined, but a control and audit mechanism must always stand behind them.
- A family constitution is written for each company. It sets who runs which area and the rules of management, backed by educating the next generation, professional managers and a strong “brain team.”
What Is Institutionalization, and Why Do Family Businesses Struggle With It?
Institutionalization is the shift from a company that depends on its founder’s or one person’s decisions to one that is run by written rules, separate departments, defined authorities and regular financial reporting. In family businesses the process is painful because a founding generation that grew through hard work finds it hard to hand over control. The answer is to give authority to professionals and to put a strong control mechanism behind it.
In the interview Nuri Kuşçu describes institutionalization not as an abstract idea but through concrete tools: separate departments, managers who are experts in their field, a daily cash-flow table, a budget prepared in December and a balance sheet presented to the board every month.
In his view many companies in Türkiye “look like giants from the outside,” but once you step inside these structures either do not exist or exist only on paper. As a company grows, it has to grow and separate its departments too.
For family businesses his framework is the family constitution: a document drafted specifically for each company that puts the rules and definitions of management, and each family member’s area of responsibility, in writing in advance.
- 1995The year Kuşçu opened his first accounting office in Bakırköy
- ~40 yrsExperience in finance, audit and company management
- 9 firmsCompanies in the German-partnered textile group where he rose to general manager
- 5 → 1Minimum shareholders of a Turkish joint-stock company: 5 under the old code, 1 today
From an Office in Bakırköy to Holding Management: A 40-Year Journey
What Kuşçu says about institutionalization comes from his own career: from a small accounting office to general manager and CFO roles in large company groups, and from there to court expert work and concordat commissions.
- 1982
From Tokat to Istanbul
Born in Tokat in 1963, Kuşçu finished secondary and high school in Tokat and came to Istanbul; he graduated from the Department of Economics at Istanbul University’s Faculty of Economics and studied a second field at Anadolu University.
- 1995
First office: Bakırköy
After obtaining his chartered accountant licence he opened his first office in Bakırköy and ran it for about six years, then decided to work inside companies.
- GENERAL MANAGER
A German-partnered textile group
At the Samteks group of nine companies he rose from finance manager to general manager and worked for 7–8 years with first-degree signing authority. In the textile crisis after 2000 the group went into concordat.
- DIRECTOR
Fuel sector
He served as finance director at Bölünmez Petrolcülük A.Ş., known for the M-Oil brand, and left when part of the group was transferred to the Demirören Group.
- CFO
Holding and group companies
He worked as CFO at Ulusoy Holding; when the holding split into three groups he moved into board advisory work. In 2013, as CFO of Flokser Group, known for the Sertex brand, he helped bring the companies under a holding and prepare a family constitution.
- TODAY
Court and concordat files
Alongside his accounting practice he now examines company files as a court expert, trustee and concordat commissioner, and advises Yangın Kriminal.
His three court roles today
Court expert
The specialist a court or prosecutor turns to on matters that require special knowledge. In financial files the expert reports on the financial side of the case through commercial books, balance sheets and cash movements.
Trustee
A person appointed by court order to manage or supervise a company or its assets. The trustee goes inside the company and sees records, authorities and money flows first-hand.
Concordat commissioner
The person a court appoints in the concordat (court-supervised restructuring) of a company that cannot pay its debts or is at risk of not paying them; the commissioner supervises the debtor’s activities and reports to the court.
Yangın Kriminal note: Bankruptcy postponement no longer exists
Kuşçu’s reminder that “bankruptcy postponement was very popular in those years” matters: the postponement of bankruptcy was abolished in 2018 by Law No. 7101 and the concordat was redesigned (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law, Art. 285 ff.). Today a company in financial distress can apply for concordat with an independent audit report showing that its preliminary concordat plan is achievable; when the court grants a temporary respite it appoints a concordat commissioner.
Why Is Institutionalizing Painful? “A Giant Outside, a Small Shop Inside”
For Kuşçu, institutionalization is painful in every growing company. In family businesses the pain also has emotional and cultural roots.
The boss who started with two machines and grew by hand
Kuşçu points out that most business owners in Türkiye, apart from the latest generation, came to Istanbul as children and had a hard time: they started with two machines, grew to three, then five, breathing in textile, metal or lathe dust along the way. A founder who got there through his own labour finds it hard to leave hard-earned money and decisions to someone else. The result: the company grows, but management stays with one person.
Three obstacles to institutionalization
Not letting go
Fear that hard-earned money will suddenly disappear, be squandered or be used carelessly stops owners from giving managers authority.
Departments that never separate
Even as the company grows, finance, accounting, purchasing and sales stay in the hands of the same few people; job descriptions and reporting lines never form.
A top with nothing underneath
By family tradition the elders usually sit at the top; this comes from respect, and education or expertise is not asked for. For Kuşçu that is not the problem; the problem is failing to build a professional team underneath.
The six core units of an institutional company
For Kuşçu each unit should be managed separately, led by a professional who truly knows the job:
01Finance
A manager trained in finance who knows capital-market rules, how to obtain loans, repayment schedules and how to prepare credit files. In export-heavy companies the foreign-exchange unit reports here too.
02Accounting
“Indispensable.” Timely bookkeeping and the ability to produce the trial balance, balance sheet and income statement every month depend on this unit’s discipline.
03Purchasing
How much was bought, from whom and at what price should be reported every month. The purchasing budget is a separate line of the annual budget.
04Sales & marketing
Planned together with the sales, marketing and advertising budgets; targets live in the budget, actual results in the monthly reports.
05Production
The person in charge must truly understand production: an industrial engineer or someone with an engineering background, or a highly experienced person who came up through the ranks.
06Human resources
One of the core units Kuşçu lists. Job descriptions, recruitment and building the professional team are its responsibility.
“Growing companies invest in their brain team.”
Yangın Kriminal note: Institutionalization is risk management
Separate departments and written job descriptions are not only about efficiency; they are also about risk management. In a fire, workplace-accident or damage file, the question “Whose duty was it to take this precaution?” is answered with job descriptions and authority documents. In companies where duties are vague, the dispute over fault and liability becomes far longer and costlier.
Related service:Fault and Liability AnalysisThree Tools of Financial Control: Daily Cash Flow, the Budget and the Monthly Balance Sheet
Kuşçu’s first rule is clear: money coming in must be under control. The system he built in the companies he worked for starts with a cash report kept every day and ends with a “photograph of the company” presented to the board every month.
Three core tools
01Daily cash-flow table
A cash sheet or cash report. It is processed every day, entered in the books and reported up the chain from the accounting manager to the finance manager and on to the general manager. It also forces bookkeeping to be done on time.
02Annual budget
Production, purchasing, sales and marketing, advertising and finance budgets are prepared unit by unit, consolidated and submitted for board approval every December. Next year’s plan and performance yardstick are set in advance.
03Monthly balance sheet and income statement
The trial balance is drawn from the books, and the balance sheet and income statement from the trial balance. Institutional companies, or those on the way, ask for them every month; even if no one asks, the person in charge of finance should produce them monthly and present them to the board.
From bookkeeping to the board: the monthly reporting chain
- 1
Bookkeeping
Daily transactions and cash movements are entered in the books on time.
- 2
Trial balance
A trial balance showing account totals and balances is drawn from the books.
- 3
Balance sheet and income statement
The monthly balance sheet and income statement are produced from the trial balance.
- 4
Consolidation
Reports from finance, purchasing, sales and foreign exchange are gathered in the finance department and consolidated monthly and cumulatively, including prior years.
- 5
Presentation to the board
The “photograph” of the company is explained to the board, reports are compared and the next period’s deadlines are set.
Next year’s budget is prepared this month
Recording as December approached, Kuşçu calls on companies to act: the budget is the basis for working to a plan and for the company’s continuity. Cash-flow tables that start daily and extend to weekly, monthly and quarterly periods are part of that budget.
- Production budget
- Purchasing budget
- Sales & marketing budget
- Advertising budget
- Finance budget
Five questions for every board meeting
- 01Where are we?
- 02What are we doing?
- 03Where are we going?
- 04How sound is our sustainability?
- 05What percentage profitable, i.e. efficient, are we?
“The balance sheet is a picture of the company; it is taking the company’s photograph.”
Yangın Kriminal note: Three statements, three different questions
It helps to separate the terms: the balance sheet shows assets, liabilities and equity on a given date, the company’s photograph on that day. The income statement shows revenue, expenses and profit or loss for a period. The cash-flow statement tracks where money actually came from and where it went. A profitable company can still run out of cash, so all three must be read together.
Delegate, but Control: The Secret of Institutional Management
Authority is the subject Kuşçu dwells on most in the interview. For him, a manager without authority achieves nothing, but authority that is never checked becomes one of a company’s biggest losses.
How is authority granted?
The routes Kuşçu describes: authority is either granted by a resolution of the company’s organ and published in the trade registry, or granted by power of attorney before a notary.
Board or general assembly resolution
The manager is authorised by a resolution of the company’s competent body. After a certain track record, authority is either granted by the board in recognition or requested by the manager.
Registration and publication in the trade registry
Once the resolution is registered with the trade registry and published in the Turkish Trade Registry Gazette, the authority becomes visible to everyone. Kuşçu says his authority at the companies he worked for is still documented by those gazette notices.
Notarised power of attorney
A board chair with sole signing authority can grant authority through a general or special power of attorney at a notary. Specific acts such as selling real estate must be stated separately in the document.
When the job description and the limits of authority are drawn and clearly declared to the manager, the manager succeeds. But even if the person holding that authority is a “full professor,” control and audit must always stand behind it.
The degree and form of authority
When authority is granted, its degree (first, second or third-degree signature) and whether it is used solely or jointly are set, and the job description is framed: “It starts here and ends there.”
“Even if you are chairman of the board, even if you are king, as long as you have no authority you are nothing. Your word carries no weight; no one listens.”
Yangın Kriminal note: What does the law say?
Under the Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102, the board of a joint-stock company may delegate management in part or in full through internal regulations issued on the basis of the articles of association (Art. 367); persons authorised to represent the company are registered with the trade registry and published in the Turkish Trade Registry Gazette (Art. 373). For a power of attorney, Art. 504 of the Turkish Code of Obligations requires special authority for acts such as transferring real estate, filing a lawsuit, settling or making a donation. The “ahzu kabz” authority mentioned in the interview is the agent’s power to receive and collect money or goods on the principal’s behalf. Where forged signatures, unauthorised signatures or suspicious documents are alleged, forensic document examination is a separate field of expertise.
Related service:Forensic Document ExaminationHow to Draft a Family Constitution: Writing Down in Advance Who Runs What
As CFO of Flokser Group, Kuşçu prepared a family constitution while the companies were being brought under a holding. In Akbal’s words, the aim is for the companies to pass from generation to generation through a written chain of rules rather than “breaking into pieces and losing strength.”
What is a family constitution?
In Kuşçu’s definition, a family constitution is the document that sets out a company’s management rules and definitions, how its affairs will be run and managed, and the principles behind them. There is no ready-made template: “It is specific to each company’s own structure. It must be prepared specially.”
Two models, depending on the company’s structure
A multi-sector group of companies
If the group spans different fields such as textiles, chemicals, electronics, advertising or energy, the track record and expertise of family and board members are assessed and each is given control of one sector.
- “Your field is textiles; you take control.”
- “Your field is chemicals.”
- “Your field is electronics.”
- “If there’s energy, energy is yours.”
A company in a single field
If the company works in one field, roles are divided by function rather than by sector; each main unit reports to one family or board member.
- Production
- Sales & marketing
- Purchasing
- Finance, accounting and financial affairs
Respect at the top, professionalism underneath
For Kuşçu, the elders usually sit at the top of a family business, and this comes from respect. What matters is building the structure underneath so that person can make good, sound decisions:
Educating the next generation
A very good education for the second generation is the first condition for the company’s future.
Professional managers
Managers who are competent in management and suited to the company’s own structure should be hired.
A brain team
A core team of specialised, well-trained professionals focused on institutionalization should be built.
Five shareholders or not, the money ends up in one place
Kuşçu notes that a joint-stock company used to require at least five shareholders, that it can now be founded with one, and that a limited company can have up to 50 partners. But in his view these numbers matter little in practice in Türkiye: with 5 or 20 shareholders there is usually one elder at the top, a board chair who controls the capital, while the others hold small stakes.
“A family constitution is specific to each company’s own structure. It must be prepared specially.”
Yangın Kriminal note: The legal force of the constitution
A family constitution is not a document regulated by statute; within the family it works as a moral and managerial agreement. Provisions meant to be binding (for example share transfers, election to the board or representation authority) must be reflected in the articles of association or a shareholders’ agreement. Legal reminder: under Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 a joint-stock company can be founded with a single shareholder (Art. 338), and a limited company cannot have more than fifty partners (Art. 574).
Institutionalization and Financial Control in Family Businesses | A Conversation with Chartered Accountant Nuri Kuşçu
Chartered accountant, independent auditor and concordat commissioner Nuri Kuşçu talks about his career from his first office in Bakırköy to holding management, why institutionalization is painful in family businesses, the role of the daily cash-flow table, the budget and the monthly balance sheet, building authority and control together, and the family-constitution approach. (Interview in Turkish.)
Financial Records After a Fire: What Happens If the Books Burn?
This section is not part of the interview; as Yangın Kriminal, we combine the financial-control tools Kuşçu describes with our experience in fire cases. When a fire breaks out at a business, well-kept financial records become critical both for proving the loss and for investigating the cause of the fire.
Five financial steps for a business after a fire
- 1
Establish the state of the books and documents
Record in a list which commercial books, invoices and contracts burned and which were saved; obtain the fire brigade report.
- 2
Request a loss certificate within 15 days
If books and documents are destroyed in a fire, request a loss certificate (zayi belgesi) from the competent court within 15 days of learning of the loss (Turkish Commercial Code, Art. 82/7).
- 3
Notify the tax office of force majeure
Fire is listed as force majeure in the Tax Procedure Law (Art. 13); time limits for tax obligations do not run while force majeure lasts (Art. 15). File the notice with supporting documents.
- 4
Build the damage and loss-of-profit file from records
Stock, fixed-asset and machinery records, together with prior periods’ balance sheets and income statements, underpin the insurance claim and any business-interruption (loss-of-profit) claim.
- 5
Have the cause examined by an independent expert
In insurance and court proceedings, the origin and cause of the fire must be established with technical evidence. Financial records are not proof on their own; they are assessed together with technical findings.
Why is financial distress part of a fire investigation?
NFPA 921, the international guide for fire investigation, lists profit (for example insurance fraud) among the motives for incendiary fires. So in a business fire the investigator may also bring financial data such as debt load, a concordat process, stock and insured values into the file. But the order matters: the cause of the fire is determined technically first; financial distress alone is not proof of intent. A well-kept balance sheet and cash flow are an honest business’s strongest defence.
“Money coming in must be under control, so it doesn’t become food for thieves or rats.”
Yangın Kriminal note: Retention periods
Under the Turkish Commercial Code, commercial books and documents must be kept for 10 years (Art. 82); under tax law, for 5 years starting from the year after the year they relate to (Tax Procedure Law, Art. 253). The retention duty does not remove the fire risk, so backups and the placement of the archive are a fire-safety matter too. We support businesses with independent technical reports to determine damage, fault and cause after a fire.
Related service:Fire Report & Expert Witness OpinionFinancial Management and Institutionalization Glossary
Short definitions of the key terms in this guide:
- Institutionalization
- The shift from a company that depends on one person to one run by written rules, separate departments, defined authorities and regular reporting.
- Family constitution
- A document drafted for a specific family business that sets the management rules, the roles and responsibilities of family members and the principles for passing the business between generations.
- Cash-flow table
- A table showing the cash coming into and going out of a business over a period. The daily version Kuşçu recommends is based on the cash report.
- Budget
- A board-approved plan in which the company’s revenue, expense and investment targets for the coming period are planned unit by unit and consolidated.
- Trial balance
- A control sheet showing the debit and credit totals and balances of every account in the books; the balance sheet and income statement are prepared from it.
- Balance sheet
- The core financial statement showing assets, liabilities and equity on a given date. In Kuşçu’s words, “the picture of the company.”
- Income statement
- A financial statement showing revenue, expenses and the resulting profit or loss for a period.
- Consolidation
- Combining the financial reports of units or group companies into a single whole.
- Signing authority
- The authority that sets who may sign on the company’s behalf, on which matters, at what degree, and whether alone (solely) or together (jointly).
- Ahzu kabz
- A Turkish legal term for the agent’s power to receive and collect money or goods on the principal’s behalf.
- Concordat (konkordato)
- A court-supervised procedure that lets a debtor who cannot pay, or is at risk of not paying, agree with creditors on deferral or a reduction of debts (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law, Art. 285 ff.).
- Loss certificate (zayi belgesi)
- A certificate the court issues to a merchant whose commercial books and documents were lost to fire, flood, earthquake or theft, on application within 15 days (Turkish Commercial Code, Art. 82/7).
“I gave the authority; the person may be very professional, very well educated, very trustworthy. But there must always, always be control and audit behind it. That is where the secret of success lies.”
Frequently Asked Questions
What is institutionalization?+
Why do family businesses fail to institutionalize?+
Which departments should an institutional company have?+
What is a daily cash-flow table, and what is it for?+
When and how is a company budget prepared?+
What is a balance sheet, and why produce it every month?+
How is authority given to a manager, and how is it controlled?+
What is a family constitution, and how is it drafted?+
Can a Turkish joint-stock company have a single shareholder?+
What does a concordat commissioner do?+
What should a business do if its commercial books burn in a fire?+
Who is Nuri Kuşçu?+
Check Today: 8 Points
A list drawn from Kuşçu’s warnings in the interview; the first half covers financial control, the second half authority and family governance.
Nuri Kuşçu
Chartered accountant, independent auditor and concordat commissioner. Born in Tokat in 1963, a graduate of Istanbul University’s Faculty of Economics. He opened his first office in Bakırköy in 1995; served as general manager at the Samteks group, finance director at Bölünmez Petrolcülük (M-Oil), and CFO at Ulusoy Holding and Flokser Group. Today he serves as a court expert, trustee and concordat commissioner and advises Yangın Kriminal.